Technical SEO agencies: what they do and how to choose one
A client-side guide to hiring a technical SEO agency: what the work covers, when you need it, how to tell real analysis from a rebadged crawler report, and how to hold the agency to measurable results.
The seoscore team 9 min read
On this page
- What a technical SEO agency does (and what it doesn't)
- Do you need an agency? Signs your site has a technical problem
- Agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs a tool
- What a good technical SEO audit deliverable looks like
- Questions to ask before you hire
- Red flags when choosing a technical SEO company
- How technical SEO agencies charge
- Benchmark your site with seoscore before you hire
- How to measure whether the agency is working
- Next steps
A technical SEO agency fixes the parts of your site that stop search engines and AI assistants from crawling, rendering and indexing your pages: redirects, site structure, JavaScript, speed and structured data. You need one when the problem is bigger than your team can diagnose, such as a migration, a large ecommerce catalogue or a sudden indexing drop. For a small site, a self-serve audit and a capable developer often do the job, and either way you should benchmark your site before you hire so you can judge what you're sold.
What a technical SEO agency does (and what it doesn't)
Technical SEO is the work that makes a site easy for search engines to find, read and store. If you want the basics first, our guide to what technical SEO is covers the elements and a checklist. A specialist agency or company goes deeper than a checklist. Typical scope includes:
- Crawl and indexing audits: why some pages are crawled but not indexed, duplicate URLs, canonical tags (the tag that tells Google which version of a page is the main one), noindex mistakes and XML sitemaps.
- Site architecture: how pages link to each other, how deep important pages sit, and internal linking.
- Redirects and migrations: planning URL maps when you change domain, platform or structure, then checking that nothing was lost.
- JavaScript rendering: whether content built by a framework such as React or Vue is visible to crawlers without running scripts.
- Core Web Vitals: Google's measures of loading speed, responsiveness and layout stability.
- Structured data: schema markup that describes products, articles, organisations and FAQs.
- Log file analysis: reading your server logs to see which pages Googlebot and other crawlers actually request.
- AI crawler access: whether robots.txt and your firewall let AI crawlers such as GPTBot and ClaudeBot read your pages.
What a technical agency usually doesn't do is write your content or build links. Content agencies plan and write pages; link-building agencies earn mentions and links from other sites. Some full-service firms do all three, but if your problem is technical, make sure the people assigned to you are technical specialists rather than generalists. Our article on on-page vs off-page SEO explains where each kind of work fits.
Do you need an agency? Signs your site has a technical problem
These are the situations where specialist help usually pays for itself:
- Pages crawled but not indexed. Search Console's Page indexing report lists large numbers of pages as "Crawled – currently not indexed" or "Discovered – currently not indexed", and you can't see why.
- A traffic drop after a redesign or migration. Redirects were missed, URLs changed without a map, or the new templates removed content and internal links.
- A large ecommerce catalogue. Technical SEO for ecommerce is its own discipline: faceted navigation (filters for size, colour and price) can create thousands of near-duplicate URLs, and out-of-stock products, pagination and variants all need rules.
- A JavaScript framework site. If your content only appears after scripts run, some crawlers may see an empty page. Our article on whether AI crawlers render JavaScript explains the risk.
- Failing Core Web Vitals that your developers have tried and failed to fix.
- A planned migration. Bringing someone in before launch is far cheaper than recovering afterwards.
When a tool and a developer are enough
Google's own guidance on whether you need an SEO says that if you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself. The same applies to most sites with a few hundred pages on a mainstream CMS. If an audit tool shows missing meta descriptions, unoptimised images, a few broken links and a slow page or two, a developer can fix those from a prioritised list. Hire a specialist when the cause is unclear, the stakes are high, or the site is large or unusual.
Agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs a tool
| Agency | Freelancer | In-house hire | Self-serve tool | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical cost model | Project fee or monthly retainer | Day rate, hourly or fixed project fee | Salary | Subscription or free plan |
| Speed to start | Weeks, after scoping | Often quick | Months to recruit | Same day |
| Depth | Broad team, several specialists | Deep in one person's specialities | Grows with your site over time | Automated checks; no judgement on context |
| Implementation help | Sometimes, often at extra cost | Varies; many advise only | Works with your developers daily | None; you or your developer fix |
| Ongoing monitoring | Usually in a retainer | Rarely | Yes | Yes, if scheduled |
| Best fit | Large or complex sites, migrations, ecommerce | A single audit, migration support, a second opinion | Large sites where SEO drives revenue | Small and mid-sized sites, benchmarking, monitoring |
Freelance technical SEO makes sense for a defined job: one audit, a migration plan and launch-day checks, or a review of an agency's proposal. You get senior attention without agency overheads, but check cover for holidays and illness if the timing matters.
What a good technical SEO audit deliverable looks like
The weakest audits are a crawler export with a logo on it: hundreds of pages listing every warning the tool raised, with no sense of which ones matter. A good audit has:
- Prioritised findings tied to impact. Each issue says how many pages it affects, which templates, and what it is likely to cost you, ranked so you know what to do first.
- Evidence. Crawl data, Search Console reports, and server logs where relevant, not just tool warnings.
- Root causes, not symptoms. "Product filters generate indexable URLs" is useful. "4,812 duplicate titles" is a symptom of it.
- Developer-ready tickets. Each fix written so a developer can act on it: the page or template, the current behaviour, the expected behaviour and how to test it.
- A re-test plan. How and when each fix will be checked after it ships.
If the summary doesn't fit on one or two pages, the agency hasn't done the prioritising you're paying for.
Questions to ask before you hire
Google's guidance suggests asking for examples of previous work, what results to expect and in what timeframe, how they measure success, and their experience in your industry and country. For technical work, add these:
- How do you prioritise fixes, and can I see a sample audit summary?
- Who implements the fixes: you, our developers, or both?
- Have you worked with our CMS or framework, and with a dev team like ours?
- Which tools do you use, and what do you check by hand that the tools miss?
- Will you need access to Search Console, analytics and server logs?
- How do you plan, launch and check a migration?
- Can you show results from sites like ours, whether ecommerce, SaaS or publishing?
- What will you measure, against what baseline, and how often will you report?
- Will you tell us about every change you make to the site, and why?
- Do you cover AI crawler access and answer engine optimization, and how?
On the last question, listen for substance. Google's guide to optimising for generative AI search says that, from Google Search's perspective, optimising for generative AI search is still SEO. A sensible answer covers crawler access in robots.txt, content that is readable without JavaScript and clear structured data. Our guides to answer engine optimization and allowing AI crawlers in robots.txt explain what that involves. Be wary of an "AI SEO" package that replaces the technical basics rather than building on them.
A good agency will also question you: what makes your business different, who your competitors are and how customers find you. Google lists these as signs of a thoughtful SEO.
Red flags when choosing a technical SEO company
Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page is blunt about warning signs. Combined with what we see buyers caught out by, watch for:
- Guaranteed rankings. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and there is no priority submit for Google.
- No request for Search Console access. An agency that diagnoses indexing problems without Google's own data is guessing.
- Generic automated reports. If the audit could have been produced for any site, it probably was.
- Claims of Google approval. Google says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, and these tools don't have access to its internal ranking data.
- Unsolicited emails offering to fix problems on your site.
- Vague retainers with no named deliverables or reporting.
- Long lock-in contracts before they have shown any work.
- Refusal to explain methodology or the reasons behind changes.
- Deceptive tactics such as doorway pages or throwaway domains, which Google warns can get a site removed from its index.
Google's separate page on evaluating third-party SEO tools, services and advice adds a useful test: good advice either presents claims as opinion based on data or experience, or backs them up with official Google guidance. If a recommendation surprises you, ask for the source.
How technical SEO agencies charge
Prices vary widely by country, agency size and site complexity, and published price surveys date quickly, so get quotes against the same written brief rather than relying on averages. The common models are:
- One-off audit. A fixed fee for a diagnosis and prioritised plan. Cost rises with the number of pages and templates, JavaScript rendering, log analysis and international setups.
- Project. A migration, replatforming or Core Web Vitals project, usually with a fixed scope and fee. Migrations cost more when they combine domain, platform and URL changes.
- Monthly retainer. Ongoing monitoring, fix verification and advice. Insist on a written list of what each month includes.
- Hourly or day-rate consulting. Common with freelancers for reviews, developer support and second opinions.
The biggest hidden cost is implementation. An audit is only worth something once fixes ship, so ask who does the development work and budget for it.
Benchmark your site with seoscore before you hire
Run your own audit before you speak to anyone. A free seoscore audit scores your site out of 100 across eight weighted areas, including Technical, Performance, Mobile and AEO, and ranks every fix by the points it adds. That gives you three things:
- A sense of the job's size. A long list of high-value technical fixes points to specialist work; a short list of small ones may only need a developer.
- A concrete brief. Send agencies your score by area and your top fixes, and ask how they would tackle them. Their answers are easier to compare than open-ended pitches.
- A yardstick. When their audit arrives, check whether it finds what yours found, explains causes and adds what an automated check can't, such as log analysis or migration history.
Because every check and weight is published, you can see exactly what the score measures and ask an agency which checks they expect to move.
How to measure whether the agency is working
Agree the baseline in writing before work starts, then re-check it on a schedule.
| Metric | Where to get it |
|---|---|
| Audit score, overall and by area | Your benchmark audit |
| Indexed and excluded pages | Search Console Page indexing report |
| Core Web Vitals | Search Console and PageSpeed Insights |
| Rankings for target keywords | Rank tracking tool |
| AI Overview appearances and citations | Rank tracking or manual checks |
| Organic traffic and conversions | Analytics |
Our guide to testing Core Web Vitals explains how to read those numbers.
The real risk with technical SEO is regression: a deploy that adds a stray noindex tag or breaks redirects, discovered months later. Automatic audits re-audit the site weekly or daily and email your team when the score drops or the site can't be reached, so you see the problem as soon as the agency does. Rank tracking checks your real Google positions for chosen keywords in your country, including whether an AI Overview appeared and cited you. Both are on Starter and up, with a free trial. Even without them, a monthly comparison against your baseline keeps the conversation with your agency about results, not activity.
Next steps
- Benchmark. Run a free audit and note your score by area and your top fixes.
- Decide the option. Use the table above to choose between an agency, a freelancer, in-house or a tool and a developer.
- Shortlist and brief. Send two or three providers the same brief, built from your audit.
- Ask the questions and watch for the red flags.
- Agree metrics and a reporting schedule before signing.
- Monitor after every deploy, so fixes stick and regressions surface quickly.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between a technical SEO agency and a web developer?
A technical SEO specialist diagnoses what stops search engines crawling and indexing your site and decides what to fix first. A developer builds and changes the site. Many projects need both: the specialist writes the tickets and the developer ships them.
Is a freelance technical SEO a good alternative to an agency?
For a defined job, such as a single audit, migration support or a second opinion on an agency's proposal, a freelancer is often a good fit. You usually get one senior person's attention. For ongoing work on a large site, an agency or in-house hire gives more cover and capacity.
How soon should technical SEO fixes show results?
Google's SEO Starter Guide says some changes might take effect in a few hours while others could take several months. Fixes that unblock crawling or indexing can show up in Search Console fairly quickly, while ranking changes take longer. Ask any agency what they expect and when, and agree how it will be measured.
Should I give an agency access to Search Console?
Yes. Search Console is Google's own data on how it crawls and indexes your site, and Google encourages using it whatever other tools you use. Add the agency as a user rather than sharing your login, so you can remove access when the work ends.
Do the best technical SEO agencies also handle AI search?
Good ones cover the technical side of it: letting AI crawlers in through robots.txt, making content readable without JavaScript and adding clear structured data. Google says optimising for its generative AI features is still SEO, so treat packages that skip the basics with caution.
Sources
- Do You Need an SEO? Tips for Hiring an SEO developers.google.com
- Google's Guide to Optimizing for Generative AI Features on Google Search developers.google.com
- Google Search's Guidance on Third-Party SEO Tools & Advice developers.google.com
seoscore
What does your site score?
Run a free audit: a score out of 100 and every fix ranked by the points it adds.
Get my free score