Skip to content

How to do an SEO competitive analysis, step by step

A seven-step SEO competitive analysis that finds your real search competitors, compares every area where they beat you, and ends with a short, ranked list of fixes plus a template you can copy.

The seoscore team 10 min read

On this page
  1. What an SEO competitive analysis is, and what it should give you
  2. Step 1: Find your real search competitors
  3. Step 2: Compare site health area by area
  4. Step 3: Run a keyword gap analysis
  5. Step 4: Find the content gaps on the pages that beat you
  6. Step 5: Compare backlinks and authority
  7. Step 6: Check SERP features and AI Overviews
  8. Step 7: See who AI assistants name instead of you
  9. A competitive analysis template you can copy
  10. Turn the findings into a prioritised plan
  11. How often to repeat it and how to track the gap
  12. Run the comparison with seoscore
  13. Next steps

An SEO competitive analysis compares your site with the few sites that outrank you for the searches you care about. The aim is to find the specific gaps that explain why they win. Done properly, it ends with a short list of fixes ranked by impact, not a report. The method below has seven steps. First you find your real search competitors. Then you compare site health, keywords, content, links, search features and AI answers. Finally you turn the gaps into a plan.

What an SEO competitive analysis is, and what it should give you

A general SEO audit looks only at your own site: broken pages, slow loading, missing titles. A competitive analysis adds a reference point. It asks why a particular site ranks above you for a particular search, and which of the differences you can close.

That reference point changes your priorities. A slow page matters more when the three sites above you are fast. A small link profile matters less when the sites above you have small ones too.

Aim for three outputs:

  • the three to five sites you compare against, for each group of keywords
  • the gaps you found, each backed by evidence you can point to
  • a ranked plan saying what to fix first, second and third

If all you have at the end is a spreadsheet nobody opens again, the analysis has failed.

Step 1: Find your real search competitors

Business competitors are the companies that sell what you sell. Search competitors are the sites that appear when people search for what you want to rank for. The two lists overlap less than you might expect.

Take a local plumber. Its search competitors include directories, home-improvement magazines and a national firm with a page for every town. An accounting software company competes with rival products, but also with publishers' tax guides and government pages.

To find yours by hand:

  1. List 10 to 20 searches that matter: the terms for your products or services and the questions customers ask. Sort them into keyword groups by topic.
  2. Open the Performance report in Google Search Console. It shows the queries you already get impressions for, which keeps the list grounded in real searches.
  3. Search each term in a private browser window and note every domain on page one.
  4. Count how often each domain appears across a group. The ones that keep turning up are your search competitors.
  5. Keep publishers, marketplaces and directories on the list. You may not outrank a marketplace, but its page shows you what format Google prefers for that search.
  6. Pick three to five sites per group. Include one just above you, which is beatable, and the top result, which shows what good looks like.

Your league does this step for you. It finds the sites you really compete with in Google, shows where each sits on the SEO League Table beside you, and shows how far behind the next one you are.

Step 2: Compare site health area by area

Content gets most of the attention, but sites often win on the basics. A competitor with weaker content can still outrank you if its pages load faster on mobile, if Google can crawl all of them, or if your key page carries a leftover noindex tag from a redesign.

Compare your site with each competitor in the same areas a seoscore audit scores. The weights are published on the methodology page.

Area Weight (of 100) What to look at
Performance 16 Core Web Vitals, page weight, mobile load time
Content quality 17 Titles, headings, depth, duplicate pages
Technical 17 Indexing, canonicals, sitemap, status codes, structured data
Mobile 12 Layout, text size and tap targets on a phone
Security 9 HTTPS, mixed content
Accessibility 9 Image alt text, contrast, form labels
Social 5 Share previews (Open Graph tags)
AEO 15 AI crawler access, content readable without JavaScript, direct answers, entity markup

You can check most of this by hand. Run your page and theirs through PageSpeed Insights (our guide to testing Core Web Vitals explains the numbers). Work through the technical SEO checklist for both sites. The free AEO and GEO checker runs seoscore's AEO checks on any page, including a competitor's.

Competitor analysis puts your seoscore beside a competitor's, area by area, in one run. Look for the areas where the gap is widest. Those are your first candidates for the plan.

Step 3: Run a keyword gap analysis

A keyword gap analysis sorts the keywords in play into three groups:

  • Shared: you both rank. Compare positions. Where they sit above you, the page comparison in step 4 will usually tell you why.
  • Missing: they rank and you don't. This is the main source of new pages.
  • Yours alone: you rank and they don't. Protect these.

Raw gap lists run to thousands of rows, so filter them:

  • Search volume: drop terms almost nobody searches for, unless they signal strong buying intent.
  • Difficulty: keep terms your site can realistically compete for now.
  • Intent: label each term informational, commercial or transactional, and put the ones that match what you sell first.
  • Relevance: remove competitors' brand names and topics you don't serve.

The free route is slow but works. Use Search Console for your own keywords, note the queries where competitor pages appear in your manual searches, and check volumes in Google Keyword Planner. Keyword research turns a seed keyword into ideas with search volume, difficulty and an opportunity score. Competitor analysis lists the keywords you both rank for and the ones you are missing.

Step 4: Find the content gaps on the pages that beat you

A keyword gap tells you which searches you lose. A content gap tells you why. For each priority keyword, open the top three pages and your own, and compare:

  • Format: guide, list, comparison, tool, category page or video.
  • Depth: the subtopics they cover that you don't.
  • Freshness: visible dates, current prices, current rules.
  • Headings: the questions they answer. Check the People Also Ask box for questions none of you answer.
  • Internal links: how many of their own pages link to the ranking page, and from where.
  • Evidence: original data, photos, worked examples, named authors.

Watch for missing page types. If the top results for "your product vs a rival" are comparison pages and you have none, that is a content gap no amount of keyword tweaking will close.

Don't copy what you find. Google's helpful-content guidance asks whether content "provide[s] substantial value when compared to other pages in search results", and whether content that draws on other sources avoids "simply copying or rewriting those sources" (as quoted by Search Engine Land; the source is Google's page on creating helpful content). Since March 2024, Google's spam policies have also covered scaled content abuse (launch reported by PPC Land). One practical reading: comparison and alternatives pages are fine when each compares real, current facts, and risky when they are hundreds of clones that only swap the rival's name (Searchmaxxed). Find what the winning pages lack, and add that.

Count referring domains (the number of separate sites linking to you), not raw link counts. A site that links to you 500 times from its footer is still one referring domain. Then judge the links themselves: are they from relevant sites, in the body of real pages, which people might actually click?

Next, look at where a competitor's links come from:

  • guides and resource pages
  • roundups and "best of" lists
  • free tools and calculators
  • press coverage of data or research
  • directories, partners and suppliers

Ask which of those you could realistically earn. If their links point to a free calculator, a better calculator is a plan. If they come from a decade of press coverage, you won't match that in a quarter.

Links matter, but they rarely explain everything. If your link profile is close to theirs and you trail badly on speed or content, links are not your first fix. Competitor analysis shows backlink counts for both sites, which sizes the gap. For the wider picture of on-page and off-page work, see on-page vs off-page SEO.

Step 6: Check SERP features and AI Overviews

Your position alone doesn't tell you how many clicks you get. For each priority keyword, note who holds the featured snippet, the People Also Ask answers, the local pack, any videos, and whether Google shows an AI Overview and which sites it cites.

The AI Overview matters most. Click-through studies disagree because they measure differently, but they point the same way:

  • Advanced Web Ranking puts average click-through for position 1 at about 20%, falling to about 9.7% when an AI Overview appears (AWR organic CTR).
  • Ahrefs found position-1 click-through 58% lower when an AI Overview appears, using December 2025 data on 300,000 keywords (Ahrefs).
  • Pew Research found users clicked a traditional result on 8% of visits with an AI summary, against 15% without one (Pew Research Center).
  • Seer Interactive found pages cited in the AI Overview got about 120% more clicks per impression than pages that weren't (Seer Interactive).

So a competitor cited in the AI Overview can take clicks even when you sit above it in the ordinary results. Our guide to getting cited in AI Overviews covers how to close that gap.

Rank tracking checks where your site appears in Google for the keywords you choose, in the country you choose. It records the position, its movement and your best, plus whether Google showed an AI Overview and cited your site. It is on Starter and up, with a free trial.

Step 7: See who AI assistants name instead of you

People now ask ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity which product or supplier to choose. If those assistants name your competitors and not you, that is a competitive gap like any other.

To check by hand, write ten questions your customers ask, such as "best bookkeeping software for a small charity". Ask each assistant and note which brands it names, in what order, and which sources it cites. The cited sources matter most, because they are the pages you need to be on or to beat. Answers vary between runs, so repeat the questions before drawing conclusions.

AI visibility runs this for you. It asks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity the questions your customers ask and scores how often, and how early, they name your site. It also keeps every answer and the sources cited. For the wider method, see our guides to generative engine optimization and tracking brand mentions in ChatGPT.

A competitive analysis template you can copy

Use one row per site, with your own site in the first row.

Site Score by area Shared keywords Missing keywords Referring domains Top-ranking content types SERP features held AI Overview citations AI assistant mentions
You
Competitor A
Competitor B
Competitor C

The same template as CSV, ready to paste into a spreadsheet:

Site,Performance,Content quality,Technical,Mobile,Security,Accessibility,Social,AEO,Shared keywords,Missing keywords,Referring domains,Top-ranking content types,SERP features held,AI Overview citations,AI assistant mentions
You,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Competitor A,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Competitor B,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Competitor C,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

Turn the findings into a prioritised plan

Write each gap on its own line. Give it an impact score (1 to 3: how much it should move rankings or clicks) and an effort score (1 to 3: how hard it is to fix). Work on high impact, low effort first. In practice that usually means this order:

  1. Quick technical fixes. A stray noindex, broken canonicals, AI crawlers blocked in robots.txt, oversized images. These are cheap and can affect every page.
  2. Content gaps on high-intent keywords. A missing comparison page or a thin service page.
  3. Content gaps on informational keywords. Guides and answers that build reach.
  4. Links. Slow to earn, but they compound.

A filled-in plan might look like this:

Gap Evidence Impact Effort Order
Product pages load slowly on mobile Performance well behind all three rivals 3 1 1
No comparison page Top three results for "vs" searches are comparisons 3 2 2
Not cited in AI Overview for main topic Two rivals cited, you are not 2 2 3
Fewer referring domains Rival's links come mostly from a free tool 2 3 4

For site-health gaps, a seoscore audit ranks every fix by the points it adds, which gives you a ready-made impact score.

Set a target you can reach. "Rank first for everything" is not a plan. "Overtake the next site above us in this keyword group" is. Your league shows how far behind the next site you are, so you can see when you have closed the gap.

How often to repeat it and how to track the gap

Run the full analysis every quarter, and again after a Google core update. Between those, track continuously. Signs that a competitor has changed something include:

  • a sudden ranking jump across a whole keyword group
  • new pages appearing in results you watch
  • a new citation in an AI Overview or an assistant's answer
  • a jump in their score or position on the League Table

With rival watch on a paid plan, Your league emails the team when a competitor overtakes you. Weekly rank tracking shows which keywords moved, so you know where to look.

Run the comparison with seoscore

The hand method above works without any tool. To do steps 1, 2, 3 and 5 faster:

  1. Run a free audit on your own site to get your score and ranked fixes.
  2. Open Your league to see the sites you really compete with in Google.
  3. Run competitor analysis against each one. You get both scores area by area, shared and missing keywords, and backlink counts in one place. It is on Starter and up, with a free trial; the user guide explains the report.
  4. Add your customers' questions to AI visibility, and your priority keywords to rank tracking.

Next steps

  • Write down your 10 to 20 most important searches and group them by topic.
  • Find the three to five sites that keep appearing for each group.
  • Fill in the template for one keyword group before you try the rest.
  • Pick the three gaps with the highest impact and lowest effort, and fix those first.
  • Book the next full review for three months from now.

Questions people ask

Can I do an SEO competitive analysis for free?

Yes. Manual Google searches, Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and Google Keyword Planner cover most of it. Paid tools mainly save time on keyword gaps and backlink data, which are slow to gather by hand.

What is the difference between a keyword gap and a content gap?

A keyword gap is a search a competitor ranks for and you don't. A content gap is what their page has that yours lacks, such as a comparison table, current prices or answers to common questions. You find keyword gaps in data and content gaps by reading the pages.

Is competitor analysis worth it for a small site?

Usually more than for a large one, because a small site can't fix everything at once. Comparing yourself with the sites just above you shows which few changes are most likely to move you, so limited time goes where it counts.

Should I compete with Wikipedia, Amazon or big publishers?

Note them, but don't make them your benchmark. Study their pages to learn what format Google prefers for a search, then aim to beat the smaller sites ranking near you, or target narrower searches the big sites don't serve well.

Sources

  1. What is helpful content, according to Google? searchengineland.com
  2. Creating Helpful, Reliable, People-First Content developers.google.com
  3. developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies developers.google.com
  4. Explaining Scaled Content Abuse ppc.land
  5. Google's Scaled Content Abuse Policy (2026) www.searchmaxxed.com
  6. Google Organic CTR by Position: 2026 Study + AI Overviews - AWR SEO Guide www.advancedwebranking.com
  7. The conference for marketers ready to win in 2026 ahrefs.com
  8. Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results www.pewresearch.org
  9. AIO Impact on Google CTR: 2026 Update www.seerinteractive.com

seoscore

See where rivals beat you

Compare scores side by side and find the keywords they rank for.

Compare with a competitor

Competitor analysis is on Starter and up, with a free trial. See plans

More on Measuring SEO

Technical SEO

What is technical SEO? Elements, examples and a checklist

Technical SEO is the work that lets search engines and AI crawlers find, render, understand and index your pages. Here is what it covers, how to spot the common problems and what to fix first.

12 min read